Researchers have proposed to use data of human preference feedback to fine-tune text-to-image generative models. However, the scalability of human feedback collection has been limited by its reliance on manual annotation. Therefore, we develop and test a method to automatically annotate user preferences from their spontaneous facial expression reaction to the generated images. We collect a dataset of Facial Expression Reaction to Generated Images (FERGI) and show that the activations of multiple facial action units (AUs) are highly correlated with user evaluations of the generated images. Specifically, AU4 (brow lowerer) is most consistently reflective of negative evaluations of the generated image. This can be useful in two ways. Firstly, we can automatically annotate user preferences between image pairs with substantial difference in AU4 responses to them with an accuracy significantly outperforming state-of-the-art scoring models. Secondly, directly integrating the AU4 responses with the scoring models improves their consistency with human preferences. Additionally, the AU4 response best reflects the user's evaluation of the image fidelity, making it complementary to the state-of-the-art scoring models, which are generally better at reflecting image-text alignment. Finally, this method of automatic annotation with facial expression analysis can be potentially generalized to other generation tasks. The code is available at https://github.com/ShuangquanFeng/FERGI, and the dataset is also available at the same link for research purposes.