Anomaly detection requires detecting abnormal samples in large unlabeled datasets. While progress in deep learning and the advent of foundation models has produced powerful zero-shot anomaly detection methods, their deployment in practice is often hindered by the lack of labeled data -- without it, their detection performance cannot be evaluated reliably. In this work, we propose SWSA (Selection With Synthetic Anomalies): a general-purpose framework to select image-based anomaly detectors with a generated synthetic validation set. Our proposed anomaly generation method assumes access to only a small support set of normal images and requires no training or fine-tuning. Once generated, our synthetic validation set is used to create detection tasks that compose a validation framework for model selection. In an empirical study, we find that SWSA often selects models that match selections made with a ground-truth validation set, resulting in higher AUROCs than baseline methods. We also find that SWSA selects prompts for CLIP-based anomaly detection that outperform baseline prompt selection strategies on all datasets, including the challenging MVTec-AD and VisA datasets.