This paper introduces innovative benchmarks to evaluate Vision-Language Models (VLMs) in real-world zero-shot recognition tasks, focusing on the granularity and specificity of prompting text. We propose a unique evaluation protocol using adapted ImageNet and MS-COCO datasets to assess models' consistency in recognizing concepts at varying granularity levels and their sensitivity to the specificity of language inputs. Our extensive evaluation reveals that state-of-the-art VLMs, including contrastive models like CLIP, struggle with granularity and are sensitive to text specificity, impacting their effectiveness in open-world settings. This comprehensive study, a first in evaluating VLMs from these perspectives, provides valuable insights and tools for the community, highlighting the limitations and paving the way for enhanced models with better generalization in zero-shot recognition.