Neural networks are known to be biased towards learning mechanisms that help identify spurious attributes, yielding features that do not generalize well under distribution shifts. To understand and address this limitation, we study the geometry of neural network loss landscapes through the lens of mode connectivity, the observation that minimizers of neural networks are connected via simple paths of low loss. Our work addresses two questions: (i) do minimizers that encode dissimilar mechanisms connect via simple paths of low loss? (ii) can fine-tuning a pretrained model help switch between such minimizers? We define a notion of mechanistic similarity and demonstrate that lack of linear connectivity between two minimizers implies the corresponding models use dissimilar mechanisms for making their predictions. This property helps us demonstrate that naïve fine-tuning can fail to eliminate a model's reliance on spurious attributes. We thus propose a method for altering a model's mechanisms, named connectivity-based fine-tuning, and validate its usefulness by inducing models invariant to spurious attributes.