While additional training data improves the robustness of deep neural networks against adversarial examples, it presents the challenge of curating a large number of specific real-world samples. We circumvent this challenge by using additional data from proxy distributions learned by state-of-the-art generative models. We first seek to formally understand the transfer of robustness from classifiers trained on proxy distributions to the real data distribution. We prove that the difference between the robustness of a classifier on the two distributions is upper bounded by the conditional Wasserstein distance between them. Motivated by our result, we next ask how to empirically select an appropriate generative model? We find that existing distance metrics, such as FID, fail to correctly determine the robustness transfer from proxy distributions. We propose a robust discrimination approach, which measures the distinguishability of synthetic and real samples under adversarial perturbations. Our approach accurately predicts the robustness transfer from different proxy distributions. After choosing a proxy distribution, the next question is which samples are most beneficial? We successfully optimize this selection by estimating the importance of each sample in robustness transfer. Finally, using our selection criterion for proxy distribution and individual samples, we curate a set of ten million most beneficial synthetic samples for robust training on the CIFAR-10 dataset. Using this set we improve robust accuracy by up to 7.5% and 6.7% in ℓ_∞ and ℓ_2 threat model, and certified robust accuracy by 7.6% in ℓ_2 threat model over baselines not using proxy distributions on the CIFAR-10 dataset.