The key challenge in single image 3D shape reconstruction is to ensure that deep models can generalize to shapes which were not part of the training set. This is challenging because the algorithm must infer the occluded portion of the surface by leveraging a representation learned based on the shape characteristics of the training data, and is therefore vulnerable to overfitting. Such generalization to unseen categories of objects is a function of both architecture design and training approaches. This paper introduces SDFNet, a novel shape prediction architecture and training approach which supports effective generalization. We provide an extensive investigation of the factors which influence generalization accuracy and its measurement, ranging from the consistent use of 3D shape metrics to the choice of rendering approach and the large-scale evaluation on unseen shapes using ShapeNetCore.v2 and ABC. We show that SDFNet provides state-of-the-art performance on seen and unseen shapes relative to existing baseline methods GenRe and OccNet. We provide the first large-scale experimental evaluation of generalization performance. The codebase released with this article will allow for the consistent evaluation and comparison of methods for single image shape reconstruction.