We develop fast algorithms for solving the variational and game-theoretic p-Laplace equations on weighted graphs for p>2. The graph p-Laplacian for p>2 has been proposed recently as a replacement for the standard (p=2) graph Laplacian in semi-supervised learning problems with very few labels, where the minimizer of the graph Laplacian becomes degenerate. We present several efficient and scalable algorithms for both the variational and game-theoretic formulations, and present numerical results on synthetic data and real data that illustrate the effectiveness of the p-Laplacian formulation for semi-supervised learning with few labels. We also prove new discrete to continuum convergence results for p-Laplace problems on k-nearest neighbor (k-NN) graphs, which are more commonly used in practice than random geometric graphs. Our analysis shows that, on k-NN graphs, the p-Laplacian retains information about the data distribution as p\to ∞ and Lipschitz learning (p=∞) is sensitive to the data distribution. This situation can be contrasted with random geometric graphs, where the p-Laplacian forgets the data distribution as p\to ∞. Finally, we give a general framework for proving discrete to continuum convergence results in graph-based learning that only requires pointwise consistency and a type of monotonicity.